Guides

TheFork Alternative: Online Reservations Without Commissions

Looking for a TheFork alternative? Discover how to manage online reservations without per-cover commissions, keep your customer data, and maintain full brand control.

Sigital Team·March 13, 20269 min read

TheFork (formerly TripAdvisor Reservations) has become synonymous with online restaurant bookings in Europe. With millions of users and strong brand recognition, it's an obvious choice for restaurants looking to fill tables. But that convenience comes at a cost — and not just a financial one.

If you've been paying per-cover commissions, giving up your customer data, and watching your brand disappear behind TheFork's interface, you're not alone. A growing number of restaurants are looking for alternatives that give them more control without sacrificing the ability to receive online reservations.

This guide breaks down exactly what you're paying for with TheFork, what alternatives exist, and how to make the switch without losing bookings.

The Real Cost of TheFork

Let's start with what TheFork actually costs. The pricing model is based on per-cover commissions, which means the more successful your restaurant is, the more you pay.

Let that sink in. A reasonably busy restaurant doing 50 reservation covers per day through TheFork could be paying €36,500 to over €91,000 per year in commissions alone. That's the salary of a full-time employee — going to a platform for the privilege of receiving bookings.

Beyond Commissions: What Else You're Giving Up

Money is the obvious issue, but it's not the only one. Here's what many restaurant owners don't realize they're sacrificing:

Customer Data Ownership

When a guest books through TheFork, who owns that customer's data? TheFork does. You see a name and a phone number, but you can't build a real customer database. You can't email them about your new seasonal menu. You can't send them a birthday offer. You can't analyze booking patterns across your own system.

With a direct booking system, every reservation becomes a relationship you own. Names, emails, preferences, visit history — all yours, all usable for marketing and service improvement.

Brand Control

On TheFork, your restaurant is one listing among thousands. Your page looks like every other restaurant's page. Your brand identity is reduced to a logo thumbnail and a few photos in a standardized template.

When guests book directly through your website, they experience your brand from the first click. Your colors, your story, your photography, your voice. The booking experience becomes an extension of your restaurant, not a commodity marketplace.

Dependency Risk

What happens if TheFork raises its commissions? What if they change their algorithm and your restaurant drops in visibility? What if they decide to promote a competitor above you?

When you rely entirely on a third-party platform for reservations, you're building on rented land. One policy change can significantly impact your business overnight.

Sigital: A Direct Booking Alternative

Sigital takes a fundamentally different approach. Instead of being a marketplace that sits between you and your customers, Sigital gives you the tools to manage reservations directly — on your own website, under your own brand.

Here's a detailed comparison:

What About the Marketplace Traffic?

This is the most common concern: "But TheFork sends me customers!" And that's true — TheFork does drive discovery. But let's look at this honestly:

1. You're paying for every single one of those customers. At €2–€5 per cover, these aren't "free" customers. They're some of the most expensive customer acquisition you'll ever pay for.

2. Most of your reservations are from repeat customers. Studies consistently show that 60–70% of restaurant reservations come from people who already know the restaurant. They're using TheFork out of habit, not discovery. These are customers you could serve directly.

3. Google does the heavy lifting for discovery. When someone searches "Italian restaurant near me," Google Maps and your website rank. If your website has a booking button, you capture that customer at zero commission.

4. You can run your own Google Ads for less. Even if you spend €500/month on Google Ads to drive direct reservations, you'll spend far less than TheFork commissions on the same volume.

How to Migrate Away from TheFork

You don't need to quit TheFork cold turkey. In fact, we recommend a gradual transition:

Phase 1: Set Up Direct Booking (Week 1)

1. Sign up for Sigital and configure your restaurant profile
2. Set up your floor plan using the visual editor
3. Define your booking slots and table configurations
4. Add the booking widget to your website
5. Test the entire flow — booking, confirmation email, calendar view

Phase 2: Promote Direct Bookings (Weeks 2–4)

• Add "Book directly on our website" messaging to your social media
• Update your Google Business profile link to point to your direct booking page
• Train staff to mention direct booking when guests pay the bill: "Next time, you can book directly on our website"
• Add a small table card: "Book directly at [yourwebsite].com — no app needed"

Phase 3: Shift the Balance (Months 2–3)

• Monitor what percentage of bookings come through TheFork vs. direct
• Consider reducing your TheFork plan (remove "Special Offers" first — these carry the highest commissions)
• Use the savings to invest in Google Ads or social media promotion
• Start building your email list from direct booking data

Phase 4: Evaluate and Decide (Month 4+)

• Compare total costs: TheFork commissions vs. Sigital subscription + marketing spend
• Assess whether TheFork discovery traffic is worth the premium
• Many restaurants find they can reduce TheFork to their basic plan or remove it entirely

The Numbers: A Real Scenario

Let's model a restaurant doing 30 reservation covers per day through TheFork at an average commission of €3 per cover:

That's nearly €20,000 per year back in your pocket — and you now own your customer data, control your brand, and have reduced your dependency on a single platform.

Common Objections, Honest Answers

"My customers are used to TheFork." They're used to convenience. A well-designed direct booking system is just as convenient — and faster, since they don't need to navigate a marketplace app.

"I don't have time to manage another system." Sigital is designed for restaurant operators, not tech experts. Setup takes under an hour. Daily management is simpler than a paper reservation book.

"What about no-show protection?" Sigital sends automated confirmation emails and reminders. You can require credit card holds for large parties. The no-show rate on direct bookings is typically lower than marketplace bookings, because direct bookers have a stronger connection to your restaurant.

"TheFork gives me reviews and visibility." Google Reviews have become far more influential than TheFork reviews. Focus your energy on Google — it's where most people actually search for restaurants.

Getting Started

The shift away from commission-based booking platforms is accelerating. Restaurants that own their reservation system own their customer relationships — and that's the most valuable asset in hospitality.

Sigital gives you everything you need: a visual floor plan editor for table management, online booking widgets for your website, automated confirmations, and complete customer data ownership. All for a fixed monthly fee with zero commissions.

Your tables are your business. The bookings should be too.

---

Ready to take control of your reservations? Start with Sigital — set up your booking system in under an hour, with zero commissions from day one.